Best Litter Box Reviews – Top 11 Models

The best cat litter box? Aren’t they all pretty much the same?

No, they’re definitely not. But unfortunately, a litter box is usually the last item a new cat owner tosses into the cart on the way out of the store, or into the online shopping cart before checking out. That’s probably because picking out a litter box isn’t fun. It’s more of an obligation. An important one.

Cats are very clean and very finicky. They want an appropriate place that’s accessible, “friendly,” roomy and hygienic in order to do their business. Otherwise, you’ll soon discover their displeasure as you clean up messes around the house.

Cats like privacy almost as much as humans, so that needs to be taken into account. And litter box requirements are different in homes with more than one cat; the “best kitty litter box” may be completely unacceptable as a multi-cat litter box.

The Top 11 Best Litter Box Reviews

Here are 11 of the best cat litter boxes for you to consider, based both on my experience and Amazon cat litter box reviews by other users.

1. Modkat Flip Litter Box with Scoop and Reusable Liner

Some cats have no issues with the traditional “dishpan” type of litter box, particularly if they don’t know that there’s an alternative. However, the best cat box will provide the same amount of space but more privacy than an open tray, while still allowing plenty of room for the owner to clean it easily. A great example is the Modkat Flip Litter Box, which I consider to be the best litter box for cats on the market.

The Modkat is spacious, tall and covered. It has a bottom tray measuring 19 by 14 inches, it’s almost 17 inches high, and there’s a spacious opening allowing almost any cat to climb inside. The lid provides privacy for your cat, but can also be set to be partially or completely open if desired; that also means all you have to do to clean the box is flip open the top without having to reach through the cat opening or take the entire top off.

Two other major advantages: the high walls prevent problems with pets who fling litter or spray, and a reusable tarp liner comes with the kit to protect the one-piece bottom floor from possible warping.

There’s no question, the Modkat Flip is expensive. But it’s the best hooded cat litter box, and may even be the best cat litter box ever.

Pros:

  • Provides privacy for cats, yet plenty of room
  • Three-position lid provides the most flexibility possible
  • Doesn’t leak and contains spraying and flinging

Cons:

  • Entry may not be large enough for overly-obese cats

2. Good Pet Stuff Hidden Litter Litter Box

Not everyone has a large house, so you may not be able to devote a separate room to the cat’s box. But the last thing you want is an ugly, smelly tray in the middle of your living space. What is the best cat litter box for those types of situations? I like the Good Pet Stuff Hidden Box, which is designed in the form of a clay pot with fake grass and ferns – and a large space inside for your cat to do his business.

There’s a wide opening that provides access for large cats and for cleaning, so this box can accommodate all but the very fattest cats. The pot/litter box also has a filtered, vented air flow system that controls odor and dust extremely well, so you don’t have a telltale odor revealing the fact that you really have a litter box hiding in the corner. (If you’re wondering how big this thing is, the pot is 42 inches tall including the ferns and 64 inches in circumference.)

Finding a pan to put inside the box can be a chore, but it really isn’t necessary; you can put litter directly into the inside of the pot. You might want to find better looking plants for the top, though, since the ferns look sort of tacky. That aside, this is a cool idea and the best cat litter box for small apartment or crowded home environments.

Pros:

  • Great way to place litter box in living space
  • Provides privacy for cats, yet plenty of room
  • Controls odor well

Cons:

  • Polypropylene pot and plastic ferns may be out of place in upscale décors
  • Entry may not be large enough for overly-obese cats
  • Expensive for a litter box (although not for a piece of “art”)

3. PetSafe ScoopFree Ultra Self-Cleaning Cat Litter Box

You’re sick of cleaning the litter box? You can’t find the right combination of box and litter to control the smell adequately? Meet the ScoopFree Ultra Self Cleaning Litter Box, the best cat litter box for odor control which can clean itself for weeks at a time.

This isn’t one of those rickety automatic contraptions you see in discount stores or on late-night infomercials. It’s very expensive, and it only works with special trays that are pre-filled with ScoopFree Crystal Litter (a best rated cat litter for odor control), making it even more expensive to operate. But once you set this baby up and plug it in, it truly is on autopilot. Sensors start a 20-minute timer when your cat uses the box; that’s how long it takes the crystal litter to absorb odors and moisture, and dehydrate feces. At the 20-minute mark (the time can be adjusted), a rake sweeps the litter to push the waste into a secure waste trap, and the box is ready for another use. All you have to do is change the tray every few weeks.

This is a well-built unit so you shouldn’t have the mechanical problems that lesser automated systems are known for. It comes with a privacy hood, too, and even a “cat usage tracker.” If you hate cleaning up after your cat and have the money to do something about it, this is one of the best litter boxes that money can buy.

Pros:

  • Exceptional odor control
  • Eliminates daily litter box cleanings
  • Leak-proof tray and covered, out-of-sight waste trap

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Requires specific pre-filled litter trays, which are expensive
  • Expensive

4. Clevercat Top Entry Litterbox

At first glance, you might think this is a bad idea – a covered litter box that cats climb into (and leave) through a hole in the cover. But this Clevercat design has won awards, and as it turns out, most cats enjoy the slight challenge of climbing or jumping onto the top of the box in order to get inside. Providing fun for your cat isn’t the real beauty of the design, however; the top-entry system is also very effective protection for the litter box if you own dogs.

The bottom of this litter box is 20 by 15 inches and it’s 15 inches tall, a good height but one which won’t defeat most cats’ jumping ability. The top opening is nine inches in circumference, large enough for normal-sized cats. And the side walls help control odor, and are great if you have cats who fling litter or spray regularly. The entire top, of course, can be removed for easy cleaning or changing the litter. You’ll need custom Clevercat liners to fit the box, but if you have problems keeping dogs out of your cat’s private space, this is the best kitty litter box for the task.

Pros:

  • Deters most dogs from interfering with litter box
  • Most cats enjoy the challenge of jumping in and climbing out
  • High walls prevent issues with spraying and flinging

Cons:

  • Some cats may take some time to figure out how to use it
  • Special custom liners required
  • Not recommended for very large or disabled cats

5. Petmate Giant Litter Pan for Cat

The Petmate really is a giant, and it’s a very good choice for those who prefer a more traditional box. Its large size also makes it perhaps the best litter box for multiple cats. This monster is 27 by 17 inches and can hold well over 30 pounds of litter; there are also two small storage compartments for scoopers or cleaning products on the side. The Petmate is made from plastic with built-in antimicrobial Microban protection, to stop the growth of microorganisms that create odors and disease.

If you have more than one cat, any expert (or owner) will tell you that you should have at least one litter box in your home for each of your cats. That’s always a great idea, but you can cheat at least a little with the Petmate Giant, which should easily accommodate three or four kitties without an issue. It’s the best cat litter box for multiple cats, and at only about twenty bucks, it’s a cheap litter box, too.

Pros:

  • Huge and inexpensive
  • Best multi cat litter box
  • Storage areas can come in handy

Cons:

  • No hood, allowing for spraying and flinging
  • No special odor-protection
  • Requires extra-large liners (if you use liners)

6. Nature’s Miracle Disposable Litter Box

You could probably get most cat owners to agree on two things: their cats are adorable, and they hate dealing with their cats’ boxes. There are ways to minimize the attention a cat’s litter box requires, like buying the expensive ScoopFree model I reviewed earlier. But sooner or later, you’re going to have to empty the box completely and clean it.

Unless you use a product like the Nature’s Miracle box, that is. This is an inexpensive solution that’s made out of sturdy recycled paper with built-in baking soda. The paper won’t shred even with continued exposure to urine, and it’s a breathable material that, combined with the baking soda, does an amazing job of containing and eliminating odor for long periods of time. It also dries out the litter quickly, as long as you stir it once or twice a day. You can probably tell where I’m going with this; every three to four weeks, you just pick up the entire box and throw it out (and it can go into landfills, another plus).

Paper litter boxes may not sound like a great idea at first, and will probably never be the best rated cat litter box on anyone’s list. But they’re cheap, they do a very good job with odors – and they’re the only box you can just toss in the trash instead of cleaning. Nature’s Miracle is available in three sizes.

Pros:

  • Can simply be thrown away after a few weeks
  • Great odor control
  • Very inexpensive

Cons:

  • No hood, allowing for flinging and spraying
  • Not suitable for use on hardwood floors
  • Relatively shallow

7. Catit Jumbo Hooded Cat Litter Pan

It’s not hard to find a hooded cat litter box. Amazon has dozens of them, and they fill the shelves in cat stores. But finding one that’s big enough for multi-cat households is a lot tougher. The Hagen CatIt is one of the biggest, measuring 22 by 17 inches and standing a full 18 inches tall. The opening for your cats is big too, right around 10 by 10 inches, with a two-way flap that’s easy for them to push and helps keep odors inside. There’s plenty of room for your cats to get in, and plenty of room for them to do what they need to do inside.

This hooded box has a carbon filter on the top to help with taming odors; one comes with your purchase and replacements are inexpensive to purchase. The hood lifts up to allow for cleaning, and with a little work can be completely removed if necessary (as can the cat flap, if you prefer to leave the entryway open or your cat can’t figure out how to get in). This isn’t the best litterbox you’ll ever find, but it’s very good and it’s the biggest – making it perfect for many homes with huge or multiple cats.

Pros:

  • One of the largest litter boxes available, great for multi-cat homes
  • Carbon filter for added odor control
  • Entry/exit flap for extra protection and privacy

Cons:

  • Urine from high-peeing cats can drip down box walls and out of the corner
  • Flap may have to be removed for some cats
  • Requires purchase of replacement carbon filters

8. Nature’s Miracle Advanced Corner Hooded Cat Litter Box

This box is almost the same size as the Hagen CatIt, and I almost placed it above the Hagen in this collection of best cat litter box reviews. The reasons it’s ranked just a bit lower are that there’s no cat flap, and the large hood is slightly more difficult to remove for cleaning.

There are a few advantages to this model over the Hagen, though. One is that it has a sleeker space-saving design, meant to be able to fit into the corners of rooms more easily. Another is that the plastic has been treated with Ionpure antimicrobial protection to stop odor-causing bacteria from growing, in addition to having an anti-odor charcoal filter. Bottom line: either the Nature’s Miracle or Hagen is a great choice for huge cats or a number of smaller ones.

Pros:

  • Very large litter box
  • Space-saving design to fit into corners
  • Antimicrobial protection against odors and germs

Cons:

  • No entry/exit flap
  • Slightly difficult to remove the large hood
  • Requires purchase of replacement carbon filters

9. Petmate Clean Step Litter Dome

Here’s one more very large litter box. Petmate calls it “sleek” and “futuristic.” I think it’s ugly, because the Clean Step Litter Dome is a shiny plastic dome that looks like it’s been taken from a 1960s movie studio’s special effects department. At any rate, it will fit just about any size of cat because of its circular shape, even though it’s only 12 inches wide.

The opening has no cover and is also rather oddly constructed, with small steps leading up into the actual box. The steps aren’t for your cat, they’re there to provide a barrier to litter falling out or being tracked out by your cat. It doesn’t work perfectly, but it’s a good idea.

Once again, a carbon filter is built into the top of the dome to help cut down on odors. But also once again, you have to remove the entire dome with two hands in order to get in to do your scooping and cleaning. That makes for a little inconvenience, but nothing that would be a deal-breaker if you like the look of this rather-unique litter box. Four colors are available.

Pros:

  • Large litter box
  • Steps provide some protection against litter tracking
  • One carbon filter included

Cons:

  • Odd shape and look
  • Slightly inconvenient to remove the dome
  • No entry/exit flap

10. Omega Paw Self-Cleaning Litter Box

The Omega Paw is based on an interesting idea. Just be sure that you’re dexterous or can follow directions very carefully before taking it for a spin. It’s a “self-cleaning” litter box that doesn’t rely on electricity and rakes; the description is accurate if you define “self-cleaning” as “owner rolling the box on the floor.”

Here’s the explanation. This is a decent-sized hooded litter box with an unflapped opening. Inside, however, there are two compartments separated by a screen. The large compartment holds the litter and is where the cat does his business. When he’s done, you roll the box on its side so the litter falls through the screen into the smaller compartment and the waste falls into a pan. You remove the pan for dumping and then roll the litter box to its upright position, at which point the litter falls back into the main compartment for the cat’s next visit. You have to use clumping or silica litter for the procedure to work well.

This Omega box is pretty good at containing odors, and if you put it together and use it correctly you can clean it regularly without having to scoop. Some may find the process too unwieldy or untraditional to like it, but many cat owners have adapted and thrown away their scoops for good.

Pros:

  • Lets you avoid scooping waste
  • Good odor protection
  • Inexpensive

Cons:

  • Can only use clumping or silica litter
  • Some older or less coordinated users may have problems
  • Must be assembled perfectly or litter will spill out when tipped

11. Petphabet Litter Box with Lid – Jumbo Hooded Kitty Litter Pan

I’ll finish with one more very large hooded box, which is quite similar to the ones already reviewed: it can fit most large Cats or several smaller ones, it’s made from plastic with antimicrobial treatment, and the walls prevent most issues with spraying and flinging.

It also has some of the negatives associated with many hooded boxes: no entry flap, the entire hood must be removed for cleaning, and there’s no anti-odor filter. The added negatives here are that even though large cats can fit inside the Petphabet the entry size is smaller (8 by 7 inches) than on the other litter boxes listed above it, and it’s more expensive than some competitors.

This is a good large litter box, just not as good as the ones ranked above it.

Pros:

  • Very large litter box
  • Antimicrobial treatment on the inside plastic
  • Prevents most spraying and flinging

Cons:

  • Somewhat small entry/exit doorway
  • No entry/exit flap
  • More expensive than similar competitive products

How to Choose a Best Litter Box for Your Feline Friend

Choosing the right litter box for your beloved feline friend can have a significant effect on it’s litter box training and daily litter box use. Here are some important pointers for you to consider;

  1. Cats should never share litter boxes if possible: Many experts and vets even suggest that the quantity of litter boxes should be the number of felines you have, plus one. For example, if you have three cats, than you should have four litter boxes.
  2. Size: Litter boxes come in an assortment of styles and shapes, but one of the most important factors to consider is the size of the box. Your kitten will grow into a cat, and adult cats need a comfy spacious space to answer the call of nature.
  3. Accessibility: You have to consider it’s ease of entry. If it’s difficult for your cat to get into the litter box, they’ll be less likely be to do so. A hooded (or covered) litter box should have a spacious doorway.  An uncovered litter box should have sides low enough that your cat can easily get in and out.

If you search online sites like Amazon, eBay, etc- cat litter box choices can literally take you days to sift through, particularly since they don’t separate out the different styles and types of boxes when you search.

Final Verdict

This list of the 11 best cat litter box products should give you a great base of knowledge with which to work, along with my recommendation that you look strongly at the Modkat Flip Litter Box Kit for an all-in-one solution, the Good Pet Stuff Company Hidden Cat Litter Box for a cool alternative for limited space, or the ScoopFree Ultra Self-Cleaning Litter box for a great automatic solution. Happy cleaning!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments

Leave a Reply: